The Sydney Arms was built on a site of a coffee house, where Sarah Siddons reputedly found fame through her performances in an improvised theatre. The hotel was numbered 19 Pittville Street in 1939 Kellys directory. The Sydney Arms was set back about ten feet from the properties either side of it. Sharpe & Fisher’s ironmongers shop was next door. The Cheltenham Original Brewery owned hotel was demolished in August 1954 when the entire western side of Pittville Street was reconstructed.  A modern pub replaced the Sydney Arms Hotel. This was known as the Sarah Siddons and eventually closed in the early 1980’s. Its last traded as Reflections but was known before that as Brahms and Listz.

 
 
 
Gloucester Citizen, 12th April 1845 -Robbery at the Sidney Arms: (sic) CHELTENHAM. — John Thomas, 22, of respectable appearance was indicted for stealing at Cheltenham, on the 4th of March, a quantity of steel pens and other articles of stationery, the property of Joseph Hart. Mr. Greaves conducted the prosecution. The prisoner defended himself with much tact and judgment and exhibited considerable shrewdness in addressing the jury and cross-examining the witnesses for the prosecution.
Joseph Hart said I am a traveller and dispose of quills and various articles of stationary. I arrived at the Sidney Arms, Cheltenham, on the 4th of March last, about ten o’clock in the morning; I had two bags containing stationary goods; I put the bags, by the direction of the landlady, in bedroom No. 8; it was afterwards removed to No.5; the articles were secured in a parcel and enclosed in a bag.
Cross-examined. —I placed the baggage in the first place near the bar; it was afterwards removed to room No. 8, and subsequently to No 5; No. 8 is, I believe, a double-bedded room; I missed the bag when I went to bed.
A charwoman, in the employ of the proprietor of the Arms, said, I was hanging out clothes on the evening in question;  I heard a window open; bundle dropped into the clothes basket; it was enclosed in a brown wrapper and a leather strap; It upset the basket; 1 picked it up and held it in my hand; the prisoner came and demanded it; I said  “Well, if you had sent this a little nearer it would have knocked my brains out.”  I am positive from the position in which I was standing, that the parcel was thrown from the from the window of the room No. 5; the prisoner occupied No. 3.
Cross-examined. —You did not go into the house; you went up the yard;  I don’t know whether you were drunk or not; I was searched on the morning subsequent to the robbery. The Chambermaid corroborated the evidence of the last witness in several points.
B Haywood: I am landlord of the Sidney Arms; on the night in question I knocked at the door of the sleeping apartment of the prisoner; the door was locked; I made ample noise to awake him; I was obliged to force the door open; the prisoner was apparently asleep; I had seen a strap in the possession of the prisoner, around his bag on previous occasions; there was no strap on the bag when I first entered the room; I mentioned the robbery; his manner was equivocating and unsatisfactory.
A policeman proved the taking of the prisoner into custody and the conversation which subsequently ensued; the prisoner materially pi prevaricated, in one instance he stated that the strap was in his bag, whereas it was not to be found. The prisoner in his defence attempted to prove that it was a pillow which was thrown from the window and not the contents of the bag and thrown at the servant in a playful and harmless manner.
The Jury found the prisoner guilty, and, after an impressive address he was sentenced to one year’s imprisonment.
 
The above information courtesy of the research of Dr Martyn Beaufort. 


The Cheltenham Original Brewery were the owners of the Sydney Arms Hotel in 1891 and 1903. It was a licensed ale house. The annual rateable value was set at £76.10s.0d in 1891 which, for some unknown reason, decreased by eight pounds and ten shillings to £68.0s.0d. in 1903.

The Sarah Siddons was built on the site of the Sydney Arms Hotel.
The approximate site of the Sydney Arms Hotel.


Landlords at the Sydney Arms Hotel include:

1830 Samuel Hartell

1844 Wilmot Southcot

1845 B. Hayward

1856,1878 Frederick Bretherton

1883,1885 Edwin Shipway

1891 James Trotter

1903,1906 Edward B. Shenton

1919,1939 Mrs Agnes Stephens

 

Share this Page: